Wednesday, March 10, 2010

Discipline or Discrimination?

The reality of life is the everything is not always fair. Does this justify the reasons that teachers, parents, and other figures of authority in America are commonly biased towards good children rather than ones that misbehave? Are there real motives or is it just another form of disguised discrimination? There are usually two results of favoritism; it either makes a person or breaks a person. This issue is most common in America, where children have more freedom to speak their mind and to act however they feel.

A common reason that adults say they pick on certain children is because they know that the child can do better and has potential. The adult believes they are trying to ensure a better future for the youngster who has not yet committed to their future. The elder may be applying more attention to someone who may not always want it or appreciate it. This causes the child to reject that person and tune them out because they seem annoying and nagging. It can also trigger the child to have even more negative feelings and further their misbehavior. They will begin to act out more or will feel discriminated against. Those feeling can lead to destroying relationships with authority that are vital for the youngster to have to live a functional life in the work force and personal relationships.

The other viewpoint is that of the children that are well behaved. They may feel obligated to claim superiority over misbehaving peers and cause more pain to the already troubled children. The well behaved kids may also feel ignored when all of the attention is focused on the others. They may feel their accomplishments are being ignored and strive for more attention. They will feed off the idea that acting out gets attention and begin to misbehave like the other children. Their belief is that they will achieve equal attention, even if it is negative.

Children in America are most likely to behave with such rebellion, because the United States provides the most freedom than any other country to its people. Kids are free to do as they wish, with no legal punishment involved unless they break a law. Parents also have restrictions on their punishment to their children, because they can easily be charged with crimes of child abuse.

The real question is the motive behind why the authoritative figure is condoning the child. If they simply dislike the child but make excuses to cover their actions toward that child it is all simply a plot to inflict the misery upon them. This could be an underlying issue for mental and physical child abuse and favoritism throughout the world. It also helps create a strong division between the generations of today which, in turn, will cause families to less often see eye to eye.

The key to fixing a behavior problem is to fully understand the child. It is best to look at their background of mental health, physical health, and learning abilities. Yelling, screaming, hitting, or insulting does not solve anything but creates negative feelings between people. Using patience and understanding is the best policy at first and if more punishment is necessary, so be it. Favoritism should never be shown, even if it is felt. Feelings of favoritism only provide something to use against someone in order to justify that their child is being discriminated against.

There will always be children that behave and misbehave, but perhaps the adults in the world can help reduce the negative feelings between the youth of today and authority. Young people in America need to know that they can trust an adult and confide in them. If they do not have that trust then they will depend on their own knowledge and may lead dysfunctional lives not having proper guidance. If they are treated wrongly because of their misbehavior, they will believe that the world is against them and will continue to worsen their behavior in their struggle. The way that authority in America treats kids today can change the future of our country, for better or for worse.

25 comments:

  1. I agree with that it depends on how to treat children, and it also depends on how parents are.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I agree people need to stop judging people and listening to rumors that make a "reputation". so called bad kids need a chance too!

    ReplyDelete
  3. I agree with that we need to judge people and treat everyone with at least a little respect. We need to make adjustments now so we won't have a problem now.

    ReplyDelete
  4. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  5. This post fails to connect its subject with American culture, so I cannot grade it.

    The student may repost it, rewritten, for the full grade, but I will be leaving this version up for the time being since it provides an interesting topic of discussion and is extraordinarily well-written.

    To weigh in on the subject, I completely and totally agree that adults, as authority figures, need to be extra careful not to abuse their powers. Favoritism is very damaging if it interferes with a system of merit.

    All teacher-student relationships must be based on merit. In other words, a teacher treats the student with regards to their achievements / infractions. If a student has a history of poor behavior, it is only logical not to give that student the benefit of the doubt. If, however, a student has labored to give every indication of cooperation at every step of the learning process, then the teacher can justifiably give them the benefit of the doubt, because their history has established a pattern of behavior the teacher knows will likely continue into the future.

    Many students see this system as a form of favoritism, but favoritism is by definition not based on merit. It would be favoritism if a poor student changed their ways, established a solid pattern of good behavior, and yet the teacher still persisted to doubt their every action.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Ok, good rewrite. It's not that hard to twist almost any subject to fit in! (look up the word "condone", though. I don't think it means what you think it means...

    The rewrite refocuses the attention of this post to the unique American perspective on raising children. Americans stereotypically place huge value on individuality, freedom, and equality, and in general distrust government and authority figures, with few exceptions. As Rand points out, this weltanshauung seeps into even our child-raising practices - with potentially devastating results, according to the author of this post.

    ReplyDelete
  7. This is a powerful post. It really gets to the possible root of the problem. I would agree that adults can help to influence the way we act, but there are many times that adults cannot Always control the outcome of things.

    ReplyDelete
  8. I agree that sometimes that people might be biast to some children. Being that they might give them more attention because they're bad or because they are good. However, I agree with Wykes, your history is what shows people what kind of respect you seem to deserve.

    ReplyDelete
  9. I thought this was a good post. I think a adults need to try to understand the person and try not to be too biased.

    ReplyDelete
  10. I agree, authority figures need to be careful of the fine line between discipline and discrimination.

    ReplyDelete
  11. I agree with this post. Some authority figures do not go about the best way in dealing with children.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Discipline should be both positive yet strict. If a person can discover a way to enforce a rule without breaking the child's spirit, then they've succeded.

    ReplyDelete
  13. I like your post. I also agree with Morrison. Adults needs to understand the kid better.

    ReplyDelete
  14. I think that if adults spent more time getting to know kids better it could help the problem.

    ReplyDelete
  15. I agree with that. We need to respect other people's opinion even they are little kids. Even though we think that it is not a big deal, it is a big of big deal for them.

    ReplyDelete
  16. This is a very good post nice job.

    ReplyDelete
  17. Teachers, peers. and parents are without a doubt biased towards the "good" student, or child. I have experience... Sometimes the child has a potential that they may not know about, and the adult pushes them to show that potential in doing better.

    ReplyDelete
  18. I really really agree with this post. Favoritism can lead to major problems among peers.

    ReplyDelete
  19. But problem is that teen don't think about their behaves and just think about how parents treat them. If our behavior is good, then parents treat us good..

    ReplyDelete
  20. I agree with Baker in that if a child is good, they should receive good back like the golden rule "treat others the way you want to be treated." So if a so called "bad kid" wants to act out, they shouldn't be rewarded or even left alone because the behavior will continue.

    ReplyDelete
  21. I agree with this post. We need to treat everyone with respect and give everyone a chance.

    ReplyDelete
  22. good post...Children are people too! respect!

    ReplyDelete
  23. Some people need to give respect to get it, but other then that. Give the people a chance!

    ReplyDelete

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.